There are two private Monticello home insurance agencies within the city. When applying for Monticello home insurance quotes, simply provide some basic information like your name, past insurance history and the type of policy you're looking for. At American Family Insurance, you can find exactly what you're looking for within Monticello. The Timothy Whitacre agency is located at 204 West 3rd Street. Whitacre has served as an insurance agent fore nearly 20 years and his agency is part of the Life Underwriting Training Council. You can use our convenient form below to find home insurance agencies that let you get quotes online or with a simple phone call to a representative.